Dinner Theater: Comedy, Mystery, Music & More

Saturday, January 19, 2019 to Saturday, April 6, 2019
Book Now
Lowest Rate Guarantee

Call Today For Reservations
(888) 906-6181

We are thrilled about our new 2019 Dinner Theater line-up! We’re offer some long-time favorites like Jon Stetson, Comedy on the Road, Murder Most Medieval and Finnegan’s Wake, along side some exciting shows like Reunions Can Be Murder and Whose Wedding is it Anyway? All performances are sure to warm up even the coldest nights with laughter and song!…join us for an evening extravaganza!

DINNER & SHOW: $59.95 per person**
Enjoy a delicious buffet dinner, premium seating and show. Cash bar. Doors open at 7pm.

SHOW ONLY: $25 per person
We offer a limited number of show-only tickets. Cash bar. Those with show-only tickets will be seated at 8pm* (seating at 7pm for murder mysteries, Mobfellas, and Finnegan's Wake)

Also available at our sister property, Cape Codder Resort & Spa.
Download a pdf
Dinner Theater at the John Carver Inn & Spa
January 2019  
January 19 Mobfellas
January 26 Murder Most Medieval
February 2019  
February 2 Jon Stetson Psychic Comedy Show
February 9 Clue Live
March 2019  
March 2 Whose Wedding is it Anyway?
March 16 Finnegan's Wake
March 23 Reunions Can Be Murder
March 30 Jon Stetson Psychic Comedy Show
April 2018  
April 6 Mobfellas

Call for reservations, .

Enjoy the buffet dinner, show and spend the night in one of our beautifully appointed guest rooms or suites. Your overnight stay includes use of all hotel amenities including our Indoor Theme Pool, WaterFire Tavern, and Beach Plum Spa and a $10 breakfast voucher. Call to reserve your overnight getaway and dinner theater tickets.

**Rates INCLUDE a taxable 20% administrative fee and 7% meals tax (tax rate is subject to change). The 20% taxable administrative fee does not represent a tip or service charge for wait staff employees, service employees or service bartenders. These employees are compensated by being paid a higher hourly rate.

Dinner Theater tickets and Overnight Packages are available to GROUPS.

--> Download the 2019 Dinner Theater Flyer

Mob boss Carmine Pelagatti is set to bestow a great honor on one of his top men, but in a world where murder comes with a smile, the night is bound to be marred by betrayal, double-dealing and even death. You’ll need to keep your wits about you to keep up with the cast of fast-talking fast-shooting characters and make it out with your honor and your life intact. Figure out who whacked who!
John Carver Inn: Saturdays: January 19 and April 6

Murder Most Medieval
Queen Maliciouscent has planned a celebratory feast to welcome home her favorite knight, Sir Lancelittle and you are invited! With the entire court in attendance, the revelry starts off with a bang but ends with a thud as a murder interrupts the festivities! Who could have committed such a heinous crime?
John Carver Inn: Saturday, January 26

Psychic Mindblowing Comedy Show: The Jon Stetson Experience
As seen on CBS’s “The Mentalist”, join Jon Stetson, America’s Master Mentalist, for an evening of intelligent, audience interactive fun. Stetson will keep you mesmerized and thoroughly entertained. Mind reading has never been this much fun!
Watch a short video Watch a short video clip here!
John Carver Inn: Saturdays: February 2 and March 30
Cape Codder Resort: Saturdays: February 9 and April 13

Clue Live
You’ve come to dine as the guests of Mr. Boddy, but when your host is found dead, a private investigator needs your help! Who did it? What weapon was used? Where did the crime take place? Was it Miss Scarlet with the candlestick in the Music Room? Interrogate the suspects, collect the clues, and solve the mystery!
John Carver Inn, Saturday, February 9

Whose Wedding is it Anyway?
You’re cordially invited to a wedding you won’t soon forget… because you are the wedding planner! Along with your fellow audience members, you’ll vote for the theme, music and even the couple! Whether it turns out to be an Italian, Greek or Jewish affair it will be one to remember! But... murder will mar the occasion, so you’d better plan to solve the mystery as well!
John Carver Inn: Saturday, March 2

Finnegan’s Wake
You’ll laugh ‘til you cry at this uproarious interactive Celtic comedy with tender ballads and hilarious eulogies. You may even be called upon to salute the dearly departed with a joke, song or dance! Reserve early.
John Carver Inn: Saturday March 16

Reunions Can Be Murder
A former wallflower has organized a fantastic reunion event featuring some of All American High’s most successful alumni. The nerd, the jock, the tortured artist, and the head cheerleader are all invited, but when the night is marred by murder, the entire class must work together to figure out who acted out on old grudges or new jealousies.
John Carver Inn: Saturday, March 23


Additional Shows At The Cape Codder Resort & Spa

Comedy On The Road
This hysterically funny group of comedians will have you laughing ’til you cry! A great lineup featuring the truly unique humor of Cape Cod Comedy Fest favorite, Steve Donovan; rising Boston comedy star, Laura Severse and your musical hosts “Sauce & Cheese” from the World Gone Crazy Band. A great night out
Cape Codder Resort: Saturday, January 26

The Dynamic Dueling Piano Duo
Two talented performers face off on a pair of replica Baby Grand Pianos, playing seamlessly from one decade and genre to the next. From Neil Diamond, Elton John and Madonna to Maroon 5, Outkast and Green Day. One moment, the pianists are working together; the next they’re battling for the spotlight. Come sing along and dance!
Cape Codder Resort: Saturday, March 2

St. Patrick’s Day Comedy Show: GAELIC VS. GARLIC!
The funny side of growing up Irish vs Italian! Cannoli vs Soda Bread? Prosciutto vs Corned Beef? Red Wine vs Guinness? Don’t miss this hysterical night of stand up and audience interactive routines featuring NY Comedians Tom Briscoe, Mark Riccadonna and hosted by Boston’s Gary Marino. Acoustic rocker Johnny Mac provides the Irish tunes and straight up rock & roll! Experience a night of comedy that will make us all feel like we grew up in the same house together!
Cape Codder Resort: Saturday, March 16

Loretta LaRoche and her “We’re Not Dead Yet Quartet”
(this event is show only; $40 per person)
Loretta LaRoche has done it all! She’s a PBS star and an author for Hay House, and now here she comes with her “We’re Not Dead Yet Quartet!” The show has tons of Loretta’s signature stories and stand up comedy combined with Mirth, Mayhem & Music. The girl can sing!

Cape Codder Resort: Saturday, April 6